US Supreme Court limits jurisdiction in plaintiff injury claims

After a serious accident caused by a major corporation, most people experience some trepidation. It is no small task to face a powerful company to obtain compensation for medical bills and other damages.

When bringing a lawsuit against a power national corporation, being able to find a court that is known to be favorable to plaintiff claims is a tremendous benefit. However, it looks like that benefit has become much more limited due to a recent Supreme Court ruling.

A Recent Supreme Court Ruling

The gist of a recent Supreme Court ruling – as reported in a recent news story from – is that plaintiffs can no longer “court shop” to find a jurisdiction that will be friendly to their claims.

In the case at hand, the court was reviewing a case in which a plaintiff brought a lawsuit in Montana. The case was an accident claim against defendant BNSF Railway Co., which is based in Texas. The accident from which the personal injury claim emerged did not occur in Montana.

The Montana court based its jurisdiction on the fact that the state was in the Texas railroad company’s network.

The Supreme Court disagreed, ruling that a lower court cannot hear a personal injury claim of this kind against a corporation if the corporation is not based in that jurisdiction and the accident did not occur in that jurisdiction.

The Impact of This Decision

Although at first glance it might seem unimportant or, at worst, just another case of plaintiffs facing more challenges when bringing injury claims, this is a win for big corporate.

However, this decision can have significant impact on any kind of plaintiff claim against a major corporation. This can include:

  • Train accidents
  • Truck accidents
  • Product liability
  • Other significant injury claims against national corporations

Although this Supreme Court case is unfortunate, it underscores the importance of working with an experienced, knowledgeable attorney who can win your case even in more challenging courtroom environments.

At the Gold Law Firm, we offer free consultations. Talk with us about case to determine the best course of action.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information

Injured In A Car Wreck? We Can Help!

  • Calls & Emails Returned Within 24 Hours
  • FREE Initial Consultation
Get A FREE Consultation

What Our Clients Are Saying

  • “David made a claim with my insurance company and we ended up getting $55,000.00 from both insurance companies. David got all my bills and liens reduced and I was able to put about $20,000.00 in the bank after my bills were paid.” Julie J. in Memphis

  • Tennessee Bar Association
  • Memphis Bar Association
  • BBB Accredited Business | BBB Rating: A+
  • Avvo Client Choice 2015
  • Martindale Hubbell | PEER RATED | For Ethical Standards and Legal Ability | 2017
  • David Alan GoldReviewsout of 18 reviews
  • Best Business of 2018 | Three Best Rated | Excellence
  • Three Best Rated

Don’t Wait. Get A Free Consultation Now. Submit the form and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible to schedule your consultation.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Back to Top